This place was wonderful! It was in walking distance to everything. Tony was very communicative. My dad is a bird guy and absolutely loved the decor. Would love to come back and stay there again!
Blue Maple Reviews
Every review below was left by a guest after a stay with Blue Maple — 17,866 reviews so far, averaging 4.78 out of 5. The most recent review is from November 2026.
Everything was super great! Better than expected! Such an incredible resort! So fun for families! Indoor pool! Playground! Mini golf! All such a blast! :) highly recommend!
Perfect little place in the woods - hottub was great too!
Amazing! So peaceful beautiful scenery. Everything clean and spotless! We would love to stay anytime. Hot tub clean and functions properly. (Usually an issue at some air bnbs) overall above satisfaction!
Very clean, great communication! Pretty screened in porch room.
Family vacation 2022
Family vacation with 9 people ages 73 to 5. We all had a great time with plenty of space and entertainment for everyone. The owners were great and quick to respond.
Pros:
Hot tub was so nice I love the lights, nice pots and pans, nice furniture, COMFY beds and pillows, fire pit (didn’t get to use it thanks Ian), games were a nice touch, soup just incase we forgot them, towels and lines provided. Tony was also exceptional (he was very accommodating with checkin time so we could get a round of 9 in before the rain hit)
Cons:
LOCATION (this was a con for our group simply because we wanted to go out to eat every night and it’s 35-40 minutes any direction, once you get off the main road it’s only about 2 miles but takes 10 minutes it was terrible at night too, I think this is a great spot if you aren’t looking to get dinner any night), the bedrooms (be careful the rooms are not completely a “room” the living room, and 2 bedroom walls are open at the top, it was my sister, my boyfriend, and her boyfriend so this really sucked because we didn’t realize in the photos, I would highly not suggest this if you are going with other than just a couple or family).
One extra note make sure to bring extra towels for the hot tub we were not smart enough to bring extra and had to use the bath towels provided!
Overall a great stay and would love to check out more of Tony’s places!
Great place to stay with family for a weekend. Very quiet and special place great for relaxing. Cozy and clean house.
Tony’s cabin was immaculately decorated and designed. It’s clear they finished it with a labor of love. It was nice to be away from the hustle and bustle for a little while, and this cabin fit our needs perfectly. Tony was excellent to work with, and we would rent again from him in a heartbeat!
Cute and cozy cottage about 20 minutes to town. Loved the hot tub and great wifi for streaming. This is a great place to get away from the city!
The house was perfectly clean. The instructions on what was expected of us was very clear and we had a great time! The woods were serene and a morning dip in the hot tub was the perfect way to end a perfect birthday weekend.
Nice cozy cabin with a fireplace, along with a kitchen that's great for cooking. There was nonstop rain the weekend we came, and we still thoroughly enjoyed just lounging around in the cabin.
Perfect cozy getaway for a small family. Tony is a great host to work with - super communicative. We will def be back to enjoy the views.
The cabin was nice and spacious. The location was good and easy to find. Check in was easy and that nice wrap around porch is hard to beat. The place was clean and everything is in good repair. We would definitely stay here again.
I loved the house. Old but cozy. Very close to the main town area. While the trains do run frequently, I slept through most of them. Reminded me of my grandparents house in Ohio next to the railroad.
excellent communication.
This cabin is in a beautiful area, on a wonderful piece of property - remote, quiet, and serene. The couch and indoor fireplace are so comfy, and Tony is a great host - with strong communication and care shown to his guests.
Great location, clean and well appointed house, and extremely helpful host. Will be back.
Clean and very comfy cottage in an extra quiet area of the island. Loved the screened in back porch. The kitchen was well equipped too. Better than most I’ve stayed at.
Overall, great cabin in a good private resort community. The house is well stocked. Tony was very responsive host. Recommend it.